As a property manager, you're the operational backbone of creating safe, desirable living spaces for your tenants. The pressure to balance this — security costs and resident satisfaction — is immense. Renters today prioritize safety above all else. At Pinkerton, we get it. A secure environment isn't a luxury, it's a necessity that influences occupancy rates and reviews.  

The Hidden Costs of Security Guesswork 

But delivering that level of security while keeping costs in check? That's where the real challenges begin. Over-securing low-risk properties wastes resources, while under-securing high-risk ones can lead to costly damages, tenant turnover, and potential legal liabilities. Striking the right balance is key, yet it's hard without data-driven guidance. If you manage multiple properties across neighborhoods or cities, crime rates can vary wildly. High-risk areas might see frequent property crimes like vandalism or theft, while others deal with violent incidents or public order issues. Without clear insights, you're left guessing where to focus your security efforts, leading to reactive measures that are often costly and inefficient. 

Let’s face it, security isn't cheap. Installing cameras, hiring guards, or upgrading lighting adds up quickly, especially across a portfolio. Many managers struggle with justifying these expenses to owners, particularly when crime seems "unpredictable." This often results in blanket approaches that don't address specific risks, draining budgets without maximizing protection. On top of that, staying compliant with insurance requirements, regulations, and duty-of-care standards becomes a guessing game without clear crime risk data, potentially exposing you to additional liabilities.

How Pinkerton Crime Index Addresses These Challenges

Enter the Pinkerton Crime Index (PCI) — our expert-level crime risk forecasting tool powered by AI and frontier data science that uses historical crime data, predictive analytics, and expert insights. It covers property crime, violent crime, and total crime, giving you a clear, objective view of crime risk at each of your properties. These scores are built on a 12-month rolling trend, with crimes weighted by severity and benchmarked against national medians. Your insights are both current and contextually relevant. 

What sets PCI apart is its transparent methodology, combining criminology expertise with rigorous data processes. Plus, PCI is updated monthly, capturing the rhythm and fluctuations of crime seasonally, annually, and monthly in all of our PCI countries: the U.S., Canada, Mexico, Brazil, the U.K., Sweden, Germany, and Australia. In the U.S., it even shows crime risk at a granular level, down to the day of the week and time of day.  

But it’s not only the crime risk at your location—PCI also provides spillover analysis for a more comprehensive understanding of the crime risks beyond your immediate area. Criminal activity in adjacent neighborhoods can influence and potentially heighten risks at your properties, which is especially relevant since tenants, staff, and visitors frequently move through these surrounding zones as part of their daily routines. To make this information actionable, Pinkerton uses visual graphs that organize a location's 40 nearest neighborhoods into proximity-based bands — the closest 10, the next 10, and the following 20 — providing a nuanced view that sidesteps the pitfalls of conventional radius-based assessments, which often distort risk evaluations by lumping together mismatched areas. 

For even more flexibility, PCI's interactive dashboards offer 24/7 access from any device, allowing you to compare locations, view street-level maps, track month-over-month changes, and export data for custom analyses — perfect for overseeing a diverse portfolio. 

Here's where the real value shines: by identifying trends and patterns, you can allocate resources efficiently and implement the right solutions. Instead of implementing blanket security upgrades across all properties, you invest only where needed, potentially reducing costs associated with unnecessary measures. Additionally, predictive analytics enables you to mitigate incidents before they occur, reducing repair bills, insurance claims, and tenant turnover expenses. 

Balance security spending, mitigate risks, and create desirable rental spaces 

You may be asking, “This sounds great, but what does this really look like?” 

Let’s say you’re managing a portfolio of apartment complexes in a growing city. Using PCI, you discover that one of your properties has an elevated risk for vehicle theft. Instead of outfitting every site with expensive gates, you focus on that location with cost-effective deterrents such as gates, improved surveillance, and partnerships with local law enforcement. If the PCI data shows an increase in burglary risk at another location, you could prioritize targeted solutions like security personnel, enhanced lighting, or access controls.  

Alternatively, PCI might reveal that another property sits in a consistently low-risk area with minimal historical incidents and stable surrounding neighborhoods. In this case, you might be able to confidently scale back on resource-intensive features, such as reducing the frequency of security patrols or opting for basic monitoring instead of advanced systems, freeing up budget for essential operations, site improvements, and amenities.  

Beyond Crime Risk: Pinkerton Risk Pulse

Want to take this a step further? Pinkerton Risk Pulse, our comprehensive risk management tool that expands beyond crime risk, provides a 360-degree view of threats impacting your properties. This powerful solution assesses six key areas—including crime risk, natural disasters, wildfires, electrical outages, economic risks, and nearby industrial hazards like chemical spills or factory emissions — giving you actionable insights to protect tenants, minimize disruptions, and safeguard your investments. For managers overseeing diverse portfolios, this means fewer surprises, better preparedness for everything from weather events to supply chain issues, and ultimately lower costs through proactive planning rather than reactive fixes — helping you keep your sites resilient and appealing in any scenario. 

Build Trust

Property managers, you don't have to navigate security challenges alone. The Pinkerton Crime Index can help you understand your crime risks deeply. Spending smarter, spending less, and protecting your bottom line. Security builds trust, boosts retention, and even allows you to market your properties as "safety-first" havens, giving you a competitive edge — all while creating secure environments that renters will flock to. 

Ready to transform your approach to risk? Contact Pinkerton today to learn how the Crime Index can be customized for your portfolio. Let's build safer, more profitable properties together. 

For more information, visit Pinkerton's website or reach out to our team. 

Published October 15, 2025